The Focus Pull Film Journal The Focus Pull Film Journal
The Focus Pull Film Journal The Focus Pull Film Journal
  • Full Issues 
  • Reviews 
  • Features 
  • OUR TEAM
  • Info.
    • OUR TEAM
  • Content
    • Full Issues 
      • Issue #01
      • Issue #02
      • Issue #03
      • Issue #04
      • Issue #05
      • Issue #06
      • Issue #07
      • Issue #08
      • Issue #09
      • Issue #10
      • Issue #11
      • Issue #12
      • Issue #13
      • Issue #14
      • Issue #15
      • Issue #16
      • Issue #17
      • Issue #18
      • Issue #19
      • Issue #20
      • Issue #21
      • Issue #22
      • Issue #23
      • Issue #24
      • Issue #25 - Horror Week
      • Issue #26
      • Issue #27
      • Issue #28
      • Issue #29
      • Issue #30
      • Issue #31
      • Issue #32
      • Issue #33
      • Issue #34
      • Issue #35
      • Issue #36
      • Issue #37
      • Issue #38
      • Issue #39
      • Issue #40
    • Reviews 
      • (All Reviews)
      • Action Adventure
      • Animation
      • Biography/History
      • Comedy
      • Crime
      • Documentary
      • Drama
      • Foreign
      • Horror
      • Romance
      • Sci-Fi
      • Thriller
    • Features 
      • (All Features)
      • Bonding with Bond
      • Double Exposures
      • Essays
      • Event Coverage
      • Lists
      • New to Netflix
      • News
      • Retrospectives
    • OUR TEAM
REGISTER
@
LOGIN
Reviews
0
previous article
A Fresh Look at: Daisies "Sedmikrásky" (1966)
next article
Film Subtitles & Voiceovers: Creating Character Through Translation

Review: Me and Earl and the Dying Girl

by Taylor Sinople on August 5, 2015
me and earl
Overall Rating
4.0
THE BOTTOM LINE

Inauthentic and painfully self-aware, "Me and Earl and the Dying Girl" replicates the indie visual flairs of coming-of-age classics without a chance of becoming one itself.

4.0
Critic Rating
You have rated this

Me and Earl and the Dying Girl is on the tip of many indie-aware moviegoers tongues as one of the most anticipated films of the summer.

Greg, his best friend Earl, and Rachel – the dying girl diagnosed with leukemia –united Sundance audiences en masse, resulting in a surprise win of both top prizes in the Audience and Jury categories (a rare vote of synchronicity that Whiplash managed to achieve just last year).

What exactly were Sundance audiences falling for – hook, line, and sinker? Me and Earl looks, sounds, and moves like an amalgamation of every quirky, coming-of-age indie-classic to emerge from Sundance in the past decade. But where Zach Braff’s Garden State showcased a light, original sense of cinematic freedom, Me and Earl is heavy and restrained in its laborious efforts to replicate successes of Sundance’s past.

Me and Earl and the Dying Girl Review

This vision of high school conjured up from the 80’s bin of cult classics is riddled with anachronisms that lend the film’s world a sense of self-aware, intentional construction that just does not play well with the serious tone assumed by the film’s later passages.

It’s not a throwback, it’s just painfully outdated. “A high school culture dominated by cliques and the one student that doesn’t fit in with any of it” isn’t a set-up we need to be re-hashing further. And when it comes to positioning Greg, our lead, in this faux-modern world, actor Thomas Mann never gets a chance to give us anything to grab on to, and quickly becomes difficult to muster enthusiasm for.

Greg is apathetic without recklessness; a romantic without any interest in romance. It’s the type of blank-slate characterization that worked so well for Richard Linklater in Waking Life – but here rather than being impacted, entertained, or frightened by his experiences, Greg is practically a flat-liner – hitting similar notes throughout and never truly pulling off the endearingly awkward dumb-charm we’re repeatedly told to believe he possesses.

Part of Me and Earl’s success has to be coming from the fact that director Alfonso Gomez-Rejon throws a lot of respect to the popular auteurs that changed cinema – Kurosawa, Scorsese, Godard, Kubrick.

Greg and Earl share a secret bond in their shared passion for world cinema, and their friendship is built on watching and recreating classic films – swapping the titles and plotlines with hilariously absurd or perverted alternatives (A Sockwork Orange, Raging Bullshit, Pooping Tom). The quick glances we get at their parody re-makes – an opportunity for absurd, improvisational comedy – are unexpectedly unfunny, and earn no real justification for being the center of most of the action in the film.

Me and Earl only goes more wrong when it comes to the visual style – a procession of swiveling, flipping, falling-over camera moves and random jaunts into stop motion animation that feel more like one-upmanship than anything being legitimately called for by the story.

Gomez-Rejon reveals a real misinterpretation of the impact of these visual eccentricities, and we quickly find that simply carrying out frolicking tricks of whimsy is not enough if that whimsy isn’t backed up with any real narrative density or purpose. In other words, Wes Anderson films don’t just work because of the centered shots, pastel colors, and quirky narration.

As a result, the first half Me and Earl is light and unpredictable, but also includes a definite hollowness with too little attention given to too many ideas. The second half then abandons most of that work and bulks up the dramatic firepower, hitting heavy with several high-emotion sequences, but now paying little attention to any distinctive visual style at all.

Take the frequent chapter title cards on-screen that mostly begin with “The part where…” – a would-be fun twist on plot structuring, had these title cards actually said anything interesting beyond the entirely self-explanatory advancements of plot: “The part where I start my senior year of high school.”

TFP-MeEarl-03

It’s not that the film has nothing to say – the final scenes are successfully moving, and the attention paid in these moments to the small details that make up a person’s life are particularly touching – but everything the film does manage to say is said through filters upon filters of overly-precise comedy and plotlines without any payoff (Nick Offerman’s character is layered with character quirks for no reason whatsoever and is in the film for seemingly no purpose other than to provide a marketing boost for the film) that altogether robs Me and Earl of the chance of breaking through to the types of universal truths that make classic coming-of-age films timeless.

And speaking of timeless films, perhaps most offensive is in the use of references to Greg’s favorite movie – François Truffaut’s The 400 Blows – a film that will continue to speak to the struggles, joys, and inevitable defeats of youth for generations. How strange, then, to hear Gomez-Rejon using that great film’s magical and melancholic piano score over the images of Me and Earl – a film that seeks to replicate the level of truth found in Truffaut’s introspective masterpiece, but manages little more than semi-charming style bereft of cleverness.

If The 400 Blows had insisted upon its own wisdom and depth as aggressively as Me and Earl does, it wouldn’t be a film we still talk about today.

Me and Earl and the Dying Girl seems destined to be the stand-out indie-gem of the summer, a slot held in previous years by superior films such as The Kings of Summer, The Spectacular Now, and Short Term 12. With its dynamic, fun presentation and angsty punk-portrait of the apathetic youth, it makes some amount of sense. But this is a film that tells the story of a self-centered teen learning to care for others that is handled with self-centered direction that relies on in-your-face quirkiness to stifling effect, leaving me hoping in vain for “The part where I experience something authentic.”

Item Reviewed

Review: Me and Earl and the Dying Girl

Author

Taylor Sinople

(All Reviews), Comedy, Reviews
About the Author
Taylor Sinople
Taylor Sinople
Taylor is a Chicago-based writer and aspiring film historian. He is the editor here at TFP, and has contributed to a number of international publications such as Cinema Scandinavia, PopMatters, and Room 101 Magazine. He can also be found listening to podcasts, researching topics he has little use for, or running after a city bus.
Comments
Leave a reply
Add Comment Register



Leave a Response
Cancel reply

The Focus Pull in your inbox!

Subscribe to this list, and we'll send you each week's new issue directly to your inbox. One email a week, packed with essential film writing!

Latest Reviews

View All
 
Taylor Sinople Picks: The 16 Best Films of 2016
 
Form and Function in Alex Ross Perry’s “Queen of Earth&...
 
Digging for Fire and Unexpected: Husband and Wife Process Parenthoo...
 
Every Thing Will Be Fine 3D Review

Latest Features

View All
 
Taylor Sinople Picks – The 17 Best Films of 2017
 
Taylor Sinople Picks: The 16 Best Films of 2016
 
Taylor Sinople’s Top 10 Films of 2015: “The Duke of Bur...
 
8 Films to See at the 51st Chicago International Film Festival

Our Partners

Advertisement

FESTIVAL COVERAGE

View All
 
8 Films to See at the 51st Chicago International Film Festival
 
Every Thing Will Be Fine 3D Review
 
Berlinale 2015: Eisenstein in Guanajuato
 
Berlinale 2015: Sworn Virgin
 
Berlinale 2015: Under Electric Clouds

LISTS

View All
 
Taylor Sinople Picks – The 17 Best Films of 2017
 
SNL40: A Look Back at 40 Years of SNL in Film
 
Six Must-See British Films Opening in 2015
 
Oscars 2015: Ranking the Best Picture Nominees
 
Our 26 Most Anticipated Films of 2015
Tweets by @thefocuspull
  • "Popcorn - check. Soda - check...I have a date with Netflix on Friday night." - Sherry
  • "[…] nails it.” I disagree, and frankly wonder what movies John is talking about. The original G..." - Dear Godzilla Fans: Please Stop Defending that ...
  • "[…] www.thefocuspull.com […]" - Annie Hall
  • "[…] more vibrant monologue or confrontation, like the dinner scene that comes at just the right time ..." - Taylor Sinople's Top 10 Films of 2015
  • "[…] of the year is also the stuff of a best picture winner. With Michael Keaton, hot off praise from ..." - Taylor Sinople's Top 10 Films of 2015
TRENDING ON TFP
   
Try a different filter
© 2014 THE FOCUS PULL FILM JOURNAL
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.